Showing posts with label politicians. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politicians. Show all posts

Monday, November 9, 2009

Revival - shallow thoughts and campaign unleashed

I mean maybe this blog will revive. I'm not proud of neglecting it - although not deliberately - but sometimes there is no time, or if there is still some, than energy lacks. Anyway I made promises that remained unfulfilled, however, I didn't really find suitable topics to deal with as I was not convinced that apart banalities I could be able to express anything half-original. And only repeating what others already explained - I would spare myself from this kind of self-promotion.
Nevertheless, at the moment I'm in the middle of a savage electoral capmaign, the prize is the seat of the president of Romania, among the contenders we can find Mr. Basescu, whose economic talent was many times highligted at these pages, the president of a the so-called social democratic party, Mircea Geoana, a liberal candidate, Crin Antonescu, the eternal challanger, Vadim Tudor, the extreme nationalist, a literate Hungarian, a poet, Hunor Kelemen. The first three are the serious candidates, the others can influence the result but has no real chance to become head of state. Not that it would be a welcome job, I suspect. Romania, even half a year ago portrayed in Hungary as a rapidly emerging country that will overtake its western neigbor in three or four years, is now on the verge of collapse. Not only had the budget deficit soared - it is predicted to reach 8% of the GDP - and the economy declined, but at the moment the favorite theme of politicians is the lack of the necessary revenues to pay public officials, teachers, justices, nurses, medical doctors etc. The IMF delayed the next part of its credit until a new and stable government will be established.
One reason beind is the campaign itself. I'm even not convinced that the situation is really so dire as it is portrayed, because politicians are clearly seeking the way to put the responsibility for the failure on their rivals. Therefor everyone maneouvers, tries to snooker its opponent(s) and somehow convey the image that if the salaries for next month really won't be paid out it will be their opponent's fault somehow. And as the president - whose party was left alone a month ago by the social democrats as sole government party - can not easily distance himself from the problems, he clearly tried to frame the situation as if only the IMF money would be available for the state. And the objection of the social emocrats to install a knew - minority - government of the presidents party is the only objection in the wy ofn this part of the credit.(It is evidently cheaper, but the Romanian government borrowed continously in this year from local banks huge sums and with a growing risk apettite at the markets even the doubious CCC credit rating wont easily deter "investors" from buying Romanian government bonds.)
But this is only a minor aspect of the crisis and I fear none of the candidates - and no one from the economic elite - is ready to drew the very sober conclusions from the crisis: the model of the recent years at last failed to delver a sustainable growth and it is not easy to imagine that it will in the future. However, every proposal is somehow a repetition of this earlier economic policy. (The social democrats try to mix it with some populist measures, higher salaries, lower prices fro public services etc.) Romania, a realtively poor country with a huge population depending on social assistance due to the lack of employment lived primarily on the remittances of a large guest worker population (at its peak they sent almost 10 billion euros to home in a year) and made it easier for its population to take credit with the help of lower tax rates. (Nevertheless, Romania's tax system was neither simple, nor really low, but the rational and efficient and etc. markets and their even more rational and efficient actors was simply not capable to grasp it, because they only had some very superficial informations...) Although the country attracted some investment, a large part of it went to the real estate sector and real estate prices skyroceted. Just as consumption with them. (Bucharest is quite similar to Latvia in the outlok of its cars and it is striking how many prestigious companies have a shop somewhere in the city. For example Cristophle closed its shop in Budapest after a year, while the Bucharest branch still exists...)
Anyway, it stopped with the crisis, and now people began to feel the harder times. The proposals for reviving the economy do not seem to be far reaching enough: austerity, cutting of social spending (it is usually called better targeting but please, don't tell me, that someone with 200 euros in a month as regular income not deserves some social assistance...) and cutting jobs in the public sector. The latter can be reasonable but the country was never really capable to create jobs, the record low unemployment was simply a result of the emigration. Now the migrants are returning and public officials will be laid out... The problem, unfortunately is the poverty that do not allow domestic consumption to be the driving force of growth. Even not with tax cuts - a liberal proposal - when they would deliver people 20-30-40 euros per month. (This is one of the weakest points of every tax cut ideas in ECE: with a realtively low wage level local SMEs orieted towards the domestic consumers can not raise their prices for services too much. People simply do not have enough money to pay 15 euros for a hair cut after spending the lions share of their income on houshold costs and food.) But the perspectives are not bright, with a rapidly shrinking and ageing population and with the necessity to export more... Romania faces either a very long and protracted struggle alone, offering low wages in order to attract investment in export oriented sector or ... don't really know. With the strain of the crisis slowly withdrawn the chances of a profound change - a turn from a state level regulatory and social system combined with supranational free market towards a supranational level regulatory and social system combined with supranational free markets - seems less and les probable. The aging and poor ECE countries will remain entrapped.
Otherwise the non-political proposals are sometimes even worse. "Economists" analyzing the region from a macro perspective - I'm still stounded seeing how easily they preceive that they are omniscient after putting some basic data in their models - can not really tell what would be the way out. The language and discourse of these actors is shallow and contentless, full of empty signifiers and not a single world with real content. They simply repeat phrases, like structural reforms, tax reforms but at the moment they even not dare to give details. Just phrases. And it is always hard to get rid of the feeling that it is completely immoral: to make such unelaborate proposals (while only onething is certain: in essence they mean the worsening of the situation of the social groups at the bottom of the society) from well-paid positions... Even if it is demagoguery, I can't help to think of it.

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Why do statistical offices exist?

My preferred Romanian politician, Mr. Băsescu swung into action today again. At a conference entitled "The Future of Social Change: 1989-2009: Visions and Perspectives after 20 Years of Transition" he vigorously attaced the lazy and populist Romanian politicians as - according to him - Romania is in danger to become a country of peoples depending on social assistance. Mr. Băsescu - who recently began to play safe on economic issues, he even contradicted the optimistic forecasts of the Chair of the National Bank and predicted a lasting contraction of the economy - interpreted the facts quite peculiarly. It is probably true (I havn't checked it, I only rely on other data) that a half of the country's nominal population receive regular social assistance in the form of some payments. (It is actually more than half of the real population, as millions are working abroad.) But the alleged reasons for it - populist politicians, except Mr. Băsescu himself, of course, buying votes with social transfers - is a gross oversimplification of the social processes of the transition period.

According to official data the number of employed people in Romania, a country with a nominal population of 22 million, and a real one somewhere between 19 and 21 million, is at around 4,6 - 4,8 million. (Just a slight comparison: in Hungary, a country of 10 million, where the official rate of employment is not higher than 55-56% the sheer number is 3,7-3,8 million.) Moreover the ratio of active people and those who receive pensions - either regular or so-called agricultural ones* - is below 1, at around 0,98. That means: less than one working Romanian bears the burden of providing one inactive with some kind of benefits. It is usually not considered to be a healthy and sustainable situation. (It is true that the financial transfers of guest workers make this picture less disastrous, but as it is unofficial the state can not lift its responsibilities using it as a pretext, nor enjoy some decent income from it.)

The phenomenon was a result of the transition itself, when - not only in Romania, but in many other ECE countries - the suddenly rising unemployment was "cured" by allowing people to escape into the pension systems, momentarily relieving the states from the discontent of its citizens, but in the long run causing ever growing demands on the social systems. But even retrospectively it is not clear whether this treatment was a complete failure or more logical than it seems. In many cases (Hungary, Poland, Romania, Slovakia) the respective economies never really regained the lost workplaces (in Hungary the volumen is 1 million!) and even though outmigration was a factor rapidly depleting the reservoir of unemployed people in some cases (Romania, Poland, Slovakia) the rate of unemployment remained high. (Romania was seemingly an exception, but with the huge number of pensioners it is only a statistical trick.) The FDI focused policies were not capable to ensure a low level of unemployment in two decades and with the crisis hitting ECE and undermining the former economic model it is not clear whether the nearest future will bring further opportunities.

The situation is aggravated by the fact, that Romania experienced a long period of sustained high inflation and the wages remained relatively low in order to achieve competivity. The former led to a rapid loss of real value of social payments, the latter led to the necessity to rein in state income - due to lower taxes - to give a bit more to the "ordinary people". (It was also a core element of a perceived competivity advantage, although personally I consider this argumentation dubious.) Nevertheless, state income remained low not allowing to raise social spendings, but at the same time personal income was not growing rapidly as well (except in the last two years, but it was a result of overheated economic growth, tightening labor market, therefore unsustainable, and even with this rapid rise average wages remained the lowest in ECE, except Bulgaria, somewhere around 250-300 euros a month. Therefore it is not surprising that not only pensioners but other social groups need state assistance for various reasons. (For example some subsidy or support to the natural gas consumption, that can amount in winter months higher than the monthly income of a family.)

But, not denying the role of populist politics, in Romania and in other ECE countries, the main factor behind the extended social provisions - and their limited effectivity as well - is the process of transformation itself. There is no better example for it than Romania, with its large poverty stricken social sectors, shabby infrastructure (a source of balanced budgets in recent years was the lack of investment in those areas) lifting costs of social services and low wages in order to ensure competivity. From this perspective, Mr. Băsescu was not right, rather he completely missed the point: it is not a a shame but a necessity to be a nation of socially assisted people and the only option to alter the situation is to get rid of every kind of social responsibility of the state. (Even minimal ones, as for example average pensions are not higher than 100-150 euros per month, not a huge amount for decent living, but a real burden on a state household determined to lift every tax from enterprises.) But even in this case there would be a half of the population left without the necessary means for a subsistance.

* In Romania two pension systems exist, the regular one and the so-called agricultural. The latter is composed by people earlier working in agriculture during the communist era and paying contributions into a separate system.